Authenticating AWS CLI: A Comparison of Leapp and aws-vault
Authenticating AWS CLI: A Comparison of Leapp and aws-vault
In the world of AWS (Amazon Web Services) development, securely managing credentials for the AWS CLI (Command Line Interface) is crucial. Two popular tools that help developers streamline this process are Leapp and aws-vault. This article will compare these tools, focusing on their approach to AWS CLI authentication, installation, configuration, and usage.
Overview
Leapp
Leapp is an open-source, cross-platform application that provides secure access management for cloud accounts. It offers both a graphical user interface and a CLI, supporting multiple cloud providers, including AWS.
aws-vault
aws-vault is a command-line tool that securely stores and accesses AWS credentials in a development environment. It’s designed specifically for AWS and integrates seamlessly with the AWS CLI.
Installation
Leapp
Leapp can be installed using various methods:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
# Using npm
npm install -g @noovolari/leapp-cli
# Using Homebrew (macOS)
brew install leapp
brew install leapp-cli
# For other platforms, visit: https://docs.leapp.cloud/latest/installation/
aws-vault
aws-vault can be installed using package managers or direct download:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
# Using Homebrew (macOS)
brew install aws-vault
# Using Chocolatey (Windows)
choco install aws-vault
# For other platforms, visit: https://github.com/99designs/aws-vault#installing
Configuration
Leapp
- Open the Leapp application or use the CLI.
- For AWS SSO:
1
leapp add aws-sso --name "My AWS SSO" --sso-url https://my-sso-portal.awsapps.com/start
- For IAM credentials:
1
leapp add aws-credentials --name "My AWS Account" --access-key AKIAIOSFODNN7EXAMPLE --secret-key wJalrXUtnFEMI/K7MDENG/bPxRfiCYEXAMPLEKEY
aws-vault
- Add a new profile to your AWS config file (
~/.aws/config):1 2 3 4 5 6 7
[profile my-profile] sso_start_url = https://my-sso-portal.awsapps.com/start sso_region = us-east-1 sso_account_id = 123456789012 sso_role_name = MyRole region = us-west-2 output = json
- For IAM credentials:
1
aws-vault add my-profile
Follow the prompts to enter your access key and secret key.
Authentication Methods
Leapp
- AWS SSO Integration:
- Supports AWS Single Sign-On (SSO)
- Configurable through GUI or CLI
- Stores session tokens securely
- IAM User Credentials:
- Can store and manage long-term IAM user credentials
- Rotates session tokens automatically
aws-vault
- AWS SSO Support:
- Integrates with AWS SSO
- Configurable via command line or config file
- IAM User Credentials:
- Stores IAM credentials in the system’s secure keystore
- Generates temporary credentials on-the-fly
Ease of Use
Leapp
- Graphical user interface and CLI options
- Visual account switching in GUI
- Built-in terminal for running AWS CLI commands
aws-vault
- Command-line interface
- Requires familiarity with terminal commands
- Integrates seamlessly with existing CLI workflows
Security Features
Leapp
- Encryption of stored credentials
- Automatic session expiration
- Multi-factor authentication (MFA) support
aws-vault
- Uses the operating system’s secure keystore
- Supports MFA
- Generates temporary credentials, reducing exposure of long-term keys
AWS CLI Integration
Leapp
1
2
# Run AWS CLI command through Leapp
leapp session exec --profile <profile-name> -- aws s3 ls
aws-vault
1
2
# Run AWS CLI command through aws-vault
aws-vault exec <profile-name> -- aws s3 ls
Pros and Cons
Leapp
Pros:
- User-friendly GUI and CLI options
- Supports multiple cloud providers
- Built-in terminal
Cons:
- May be overkill for AWS-only users
- Larger installation footprint
aws-vault
Pros:
- Lightweight and fast
- Deep integration with AWS ecosystem
- Easy to script and automate
Cons:
- Command-line only (may be challenging for GUI-oriented users)
- AWS-specific (not suitable for multi-cloud setups)
Conclusion
Both Leapp and aws-vault offer robust solutions for managing AWS CLI authentication. Leapp provides a more comprehensive solution with its user-friendly interface and multi-cloud support, making it an excellent choice for teams working across different cloud platforms. aws-vault, with its lightweight design and deep AWS integration, is ideal for AWS-focused developers comfortable with command-line tools.
The choice between Leapp and aws-vault ultimately depends on your specific needs, workflow preferences, and the scope of your cloud interactions. Both tools significantly enhance security and efficiency in managing AWS credentials, addressing the critical need for secure authentication in cloud development environments.
When deciding, consider factors such as your team’s technical expertise, the need for multi-cloud support, and your preferred working environment (GUI vs. CLI). Whichever tool you choose, you’ll be taking a significant step towards more secure and efficient AWS credential management.